Before a Firm Threatens a Reviewer, Read 16 CFR 465.7

Repsight Team on Nov 18, 2026

A blank white envelope on a sunlit oak conference table beside a smooth grey stone and a cup of tea

Here's an invented Monday morning. A new one-star Google review shows up: "Took my money and never called back. Avoid." The firm's marketing lead knows the matter and believes the client got three callbacks. By lunch she has drafted a letter on firm letterhead telling the reviewer to take the review down within seven days "or the firm will pursue all available remedies."

The anger makes sense, but the letter is the wrong tool. A firm's letterhead shouldn't double as its review-management system, and federal law has something specific to say about letters like this one.

What 16 CFR 465.7(a) says

The FTC published its Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials in the Federal Register on 22 August 2024 (89 FR 68034), effective 21 October 2024, so Part 465 turned two last month. The eCFR, current as of 13 November 2026, still shows the 21 October 2024 amendment date on every section of Part 465. As of that date, the rule's text hadn't changed since it took effect.

Section 465.7 covers review suppression. Here's the opening and subsection (a) of 16 CFR 465.7, word for word:

"It is an unfair or deceptive act or practice and a violation of this part: (a) For anyone to use an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public false accusation in response to a consumer review that is made with the knowledge that the accusation was false or made with reckless disregard as to its truth or falsity, in an attempt to: (1) Prevent a review or any portion thereof from being written or created, or (2) Cause a review or any portion thereof to be removed, whether or not that review or a portion thereof is replaced with other content, or"

Three parts of that text matter for a law firm. First, "anyone." The provision reaches whoever makes the threat, not just the business being reviewed, so a marketing lead, an outside agency or a lawyer signing for the firm all count. Second, the list of conduct. A groundless legal threat is one item; intimidation and a knowingly or recklessly false public accusation are separate ones. Third, purpose: the conduct has to aim at preventing a review or getting one removed.

The attempt is enough

The rule says "in an attempt to." Nothing in that wording requires the reviewer to give in. If the reviewer ignores the letter, or posts a photo of it next to the original review, that does not erase the attempt to get the review removed. A prohibited threat doesn't get a pass because it failed.

Where a correction turns into a threat

We won't tell you whether a particular review is defamatory, or how to decide that. That question belongs to a lawyer who has looked at the facts and isn't working for the marketing calendar.

What we can show is how a draft drifts. In this hypothetical, the firm, the review and the letter are all invented.

A four-lawyer family law practice gets the "never called back" review. The marketing lead's first draft says the review is "defamatory and actionable," demands removal within seven days, says the firm "will pursue all available remedies," and copies the litigation partner. No one at the firm has assessed whether a claim exists. The letter's real purpose is to make the review disappear before the next round of new-client consultations.

Set that draft against the elements of 465.7(a). It's a legal threat, sent in response to a consumer review and openly aimed at removal. Its "defamatory and actionable" line asserts a legal conclusion nobody has reached. The definition in 16 CFR 465.1(p) concerns threats based on legal contentions unwarranted by existing law or factual contentions that have no evidentiary support or will likely have none after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery. A removal motive and a missing assessment do not by themselves establish that the threat meets this definition. Whether a given threat is "unfounded or groundless" is a legal question we're not answering for your facts.

Now take the same facts without the letter. The firm either stays silent or posts a short public reply that confirms nothing about the reviewer or the matter; the American Bar Association's Formal Opinion 496 (13 January 2021) says lawyers should consider not responding at all. It reports the review through Google's reporting process (undated; accessed 17 November 2026) if it appears to break Google's policies, and sends any real concern about false statements to a lawyer for an independent look. None of those steps pressures the reviewer.

What the provision doesn't decide

Section 465.7(a) addresses attempts to prevent or remove reviews through the conduct it lists. It doesn't decide whether Google removes a review; Google applies its own policies. ABA Formal Opinion 496 separately addresses confidentiality in a lawyer's response to online criticism. Our post on replying to a bad Google review without confirming the person was a client covers those questions under ABA Formal Opinion 496. Nobody, including us, can promise a given review will come down.

Keep review handling and litigation apart

This section is our editorial view, not legal advice. Firms should keep review handling and potential litigation on separate tracks, with different people and different files. A disputed review calls for silence, a careful public reply that confirms nothing about the client or the matter, or a report through Google's process if it appears to violate Google's policies. A real legal claim deserves an independent assessment on its merits. Routine pressure on the reviewer, dressed up in the firm's name, isn't an assessment.

The better investment comes earlier. A client who can raise a problem with the firm directly has somewhere else to be heard. Repsight's private feedback form gives clients that direct line without standing in the way of a public review; anyone can still post one. When a negative review does go up, any reply should sound like the firm's front desk, not its litigation department.